Voyetra 8 refill?
- Benedict
- Competition Winner
- Posts: 2747
- Joined: 16 Jan 2015
- Location: Gold Coast, Australia
- Contact:
I had a Slim Phatty and it didn't last along against Thor. Same with the Basstation II.
Trick is to get the synth (or YouTube) you want to emulate and then open Thor and keep finessing the patch till they get so close you would never tell in a mix. Bit hard the first time or two (esp if you aren't and experienced synthesist which is where having the two side by side helps as you can copy settings) but it does get far easier and you learn a lot and open up new ground on Thor.
UPDATE: just watching this video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHJbUShzbXg
It sure sounds great, but I do suspect the Lexicon reverb/s are coloring the sound and adding a lot of vibe. A lot of what I hear is using PWM. Trick with Thor is to Mod by Key so you don't get a scary sound in the bass.
Trick is to get the synth (or YouTube) you want to emulate and then open Thor and keep finessing the patch till they get so close you would never tell in a mix. Bit hard the first time or two (esp if you aren't and experienced synthesist which is where having the two side by side helps as you can copy settings) but it does get far easier and you learn a lot and open up new ground on Thor.
UPDATE: just watching this video
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XHJbUShzbXg
It sure sounds great, but I do suspect the Lexicon reverb/s are coloring the sound and adding a lot of vibe. A lot of what I hear is using PWM. Trick with Thor is to Mod by Key so you don't get a scary sound in the bass.
Benedict Roff-Marsh
Completely burned and gone
Completely burned and gone
Each oscillator on the Voyetra 8 offers Saw, Square with adjustable PW, Triangle, and a SUB OCT waveform. All these waveforms are available simultaneously. Plus noise next to that.
This means that you couldn't even use all 3 oscillator slots on Thor to mimic one full oscillator of the Voyetra 8. Also the filter in the Voyetra 8 was based on the SSM2040 (not to be confused with SSM2044 found in Korg Polysix and Monopoly) which has it's own sound compared to the filter offerings in Thor.
While Thor is great for a lot of things, I wouldn't say that it could give you a good approximation of a Voyetra 8 due to the differences pointed out above (for one).
This means that you couldn't even use all 3 oscillator slots on Thor to mimic one full oscillator of the Voyetra 8. Also the filter in the Voyetra 8 was based on the SSM2040 (not to be confused with SSM2044 found in Korg Polysix and Monopoly) which has it's own sound compared to the filter offerings in Thor.
While Thor is great for a lot of things, I wouldn't say that it could give you a good approximation of a Voyetra 8 due to the differences pointed out above (for one).
- marcuswitt
- Posts: 238
- Joined: 17 Jan 2015
eXode, I do highly respect your point of view as an experienced and skillful sound designer that you are, but in this particular case I got to object. Although I'ver never owned or used a V8, I speculate that you can emulate a V8 very well by using a stack of Thors within a single Combinator so that nobody can't tell the difference between both synthesizers when you put them in a mix. And if Thor can't do the job for you then Antidote or Predator can, perhaps.
Just to give you a hint, watch this video and tell me that you knew without reading the video's description which synthesizer that is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPC0eiM_Kp8
I think that Patrick Fridh, a.k.a. Bitley, did a fantastic job on emulating a 'vintage' analog monster by using a stack of 'humble' Subtractors. And if you can do such a job by using Subtractor then you can do it also by using Thor, despite the different basic sound of their filters compared to the original 'role models'. So far my personal opinion.
Just to give you a hint, watch this video and tell me that you knew without reading the video's description which synthesizer that is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lPC0eiM_Kp8
I think that Patrick Fridh, a.k.a. Bitley, did a fantastic job on emulating a 'vintage' analog monster by using a stack of 'humble' Subtractors. And if you can do such a job by using Subtractor then you can do it also by using Thor, despite the different basic sound of their filters compared to the original 'role models'. So far my personal opinion.
I think a stack of Thors in a combinator would be best as the Re's might be a bit much on cpu. Two Thors should be all you need to create one voice will all functions in use unless there is more I've missed. Maybe 4 Thors for left and right sounds each VCO.
Brian
Brian
I think what eXode was trying to say is, that while it might be easy to achieve the functionality the components aren't really modeled with Thor, so it will sound different... If it's close enough, especially in a mix, that's up to you.bpmorton wrote:I think a stack of Thors in a combinator would be best as the Re's might be a bit much on cpu. Two Thors should be all you need to create one voice will all functions in use unless there is more I've missed.
Brian
I personally am not a big fan of Thor's filter... Not that it hasn't been used to great effect by good sound designers, it just doesn't grab me when programming Thor... To me it just sounds dull when less than 75% open.
D.
Not really.marcuswitt wrote:eXode, I do highly respect your point of view as an experienced and skillful sound designer that you are, but in this particular case I got to object. Although I'ver never owned or used a V8, I speculate that you can emulate a V8 very well by using a stack of Thors within a single Combinator so that nobody can't tell the difference between both synthesizers when you put them in a mix. And if Thor can't do the job for you then Antidote or Predator can, perhaps.
I already explained the oscillator issue. You can't just use X amount of full oscillators to emulate that feature as each osc in the V8 produces all those waveforms. It means that the waveforms will always be in phase with each other, but still free running. It's not possible to do that with any of the available Reason synths atm (RE or not). Then there's linear FM, so even if you try to compensate for the waveforms with several Thor's you'll not be able to use FM on a per voice basis.
Finally, there's the filter. The SSM2040 is possibly the best low pass filter ever in my humble opinion, it's quite different from the Moog Ladder (don't know exactly how to describe it) and I don't think that Thor comes close at all (nor any RE for that matter). I used to have clones of both the Moog ladder and the SSM2040 filter in my modular setup.
Regarding the Village Ghetto Strings. I actually don't think it's that close to the original. Yes, it captures some of the feel, but imho the filter is quite far off. The Subtractor is darker and more boomy, while the original is much lighter and has more air. The GX1 also has a very special resonance imho. This is not critique of Patrick's work, his work is brilliant, but it shows that there are indeed some noticeable differences.
- Benedict
- Competition Winner
- Posts: 2747
- Joined: 16 Jan 2015
- Location: Gold Coast, Australia
- Contact:
eXode has tossed a fly in the ointment for sure, based on the OSC architecture alone, as having those shapes all at once is hard to emulate properly in Thor (or any RE I know).
You can stack similar OSC shapes in NN-XT (PWM is harder) but the filter is not as good overall. That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
You can stack similar OSC shapes in NN-XT (PWM is harder) but the filter is not as good overall. That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
Benedict Roff-Marsh
Completely burned and gone
Completely burned and gone
The four waveforms of each VCO are phase locked together since they're derived from the same core, however the oscillator itself is free running. There's no way to properly emulate this atm afaik. :/Benedict wrote:That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
Benedict wrote:That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
Why couldnt this be done with one of the larger Ammos.eXode wrote:
The four waveforms of each VCO are phase locked together since they're derived from the same core, however the oscillator itself is free running. There's no way to properly emulate this atm afaik. :/
Benedict wrote:That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
eXode wrote:
The four waveforms of each VCO are phase locked together since they're derived from the same core, however the oscillator itself is free running. There's no way to properly emulate this atm afaik. :/
For the same reasons already stated, more or less.FiatLux wrote: Why couldnt this be done with one of the larger Ammos.
We might actually get that feature in the upcoming Red Rock synth... I just asked them about it on their FB page...
Curious: Did you consider different waveforms in each osc being used at the same time?
Red Rock SoundIt was not originally intended, but you've given me an interesting idea. Thank You!
So, maybe there will be a way soon...
D.
Curious: Did you consider different waveforms in each osc being used at the same time?
Red Rock SoundIt was not originally intended, but you've given me an interesting idea. Thank You!
So, maybe there will be a way soon...
D.
Benedict wrote:That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
eXode wrote:
The four waveforms of each VCO are phase locked together since they're derived from the same core, however the oscillator itself is free running. There's no way to properly emulate this atm afaik. :/
FiatLux wrote: Why couldnt this be done with one of the larger Ammos.
I thought Ammo the 4 oscillators in Ammo were phase locked. Am I wrong about this?eXode wrote:
For the same reasons already stated, more or less.
Benedict wrote:That also leaves you with the problem of whether V8 OSC all start at the same phase or are free running?
eXode wrote:
The four waveforms of each VCO are phase locked together since they're derived from the same core, however the oscillator itself is free running. There's no way to properly emulate this atm afaik. :/
FiatLux wrote: Why couldnt this be done with one of the larger Ammos.
eXode wrote:
For the same reasons already stated, more or less.
We've already discussed the phase lock. Re read the posts already made on the matter.FiatLux wrote:
I thought Ammo the 4 oscillators in Ammo were phase locked. Am I wrong about this?
That is great to hear. I'm really curious about that red synth. They were aiming for a mid May release, no?eusti wrote:We might actually get that feature in the upcoming Red Rock synth... I just asked them about it on their FB page...
Curious: Did you consider different waveforms in each osc being used at the same time?
Red Rock SoundIt was not originally intended, but you've given me an interesting idea. Thank You!
So, maybe there will be a way soon...
D.
Thanks for the mention! The GX1 itself sounded pretty raw and not anywhere near as fat as expected. My approximation there was made with inspiration from the Stevie Wonder track.
- marcuswitt
- Posts: 238
- Joined: 17 Jan 2015
You're welcome, Bitley. BTW: Where can that impressive patch be found that you've programmed to emulate the 'village ghetto' strings?bitley™ wrote:Thanks for the mention! The GX1 itself sounded pretty raw and not anywhere near as fat as expected. My approximation there was made with inspiration from the Stevie Wonder track.
It was released as a refill for PowerFX called The Dream Machine. It appears they're not selling refills anymore.
-
- Information
-
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests