I just got Chenille and I'm enjoying it, but have some questions. I've attached a screenshot of part of the manual I'm referencing.
1. First paragraph: There isn't any discussion in the manual at how they're calculating delay times using BBD stages and clock rate. It tells you what the delay times are using these specific examples, but is there a formula or something I can use to know what delay times I'm getting depending on what I've set my BBD and clock to?
2. Second paragraph: I'm a guitarist (re: an imbecile), so "delay length" and "delay time" mean the same thing to me. What is the distinction they're making here? What exactly as an interpolated delay line?
I know it's fun to just use your ears to come up with settings but I like to have a deeper understanding, if I'm capable, for when I want specific results. I tried Googling around but didn't come up with anything.
Chenille questions
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 1851
- Joined: 14 Sep 2015
- Location: Paris, France
Regarding your first question, there is a table with all delay times for clock rates going from 1.5 to 100 kHz, and from 2 to 8193 delay stages. The formula is:
delay time (ms) = (BDD stages / 2) / Clock rate (kHz)
Example for 1024 stages @ 18 hHz: 512 (1024/2) / 18 = 28.44 ms
I think I roughly understand the difference between IDL and BDD, if I'm wrong someone will correct me. This isn't meant to be a technical explanation, just an ELI5. The difference is only audible when modulating the delay, i.e. speeding it up or slowing it down, as compared to the original signal. Say you're slowing down the delay. BDD takes "little grains of sound" and places them in a queue (the longer the queue, the longer the delay). If you're slowing down that delay, you need more grains than you actually have - say I have 2 grains of 1 second each in my two buckets, and I need to fill 3 seconds with them: I'll play the first grain twice to fill the blanks. IDL, on the other hand, will fill the blanks by crossfading (interpolating) the signal.
So the delay length and time will end up being the same thing as an user (counter-clockwise=shorter, clockwise=longer), except that when repeating a buffer with a BDD, you consider how long the grains will stay in the buffer (then it's called delay time), while when interpolating, you only need to know for how long to wait until the next grain (then it's delay length).
delay time (ms) = (BDD stages / 2) / Clock rate (kHz)
Example for 1024 stages @ 18 hHz: 512 (1024/2) / 18 = 28.44 ms
I think I roughly understand the difference between IDL and BDD, if I'm wrong someone will correct me. This isn't meant to be a technical explanation, just an ELI5. The difference is only audible when modulating the delay, i.e. speeding it up or slowing it down, as compared to the original signal. Say you're slowing down the delay. BDD takes "little grains of sound" and places them in a queue (the longer the queue, the longer the delay). If you're slowing down that delay, you need more grains than you actually have - say I have 2 grains of 1 second each in my two buckets, and I need to fill 3 seconds with them: I'll play the first grain twice to fill the blanks. IDL, on the other hand, will fill the blanks by crossfading (interpolating) the signal.
So the delay length and time will end up being the same thing as an user (counter-clockwise=shorter, clockwise=longer), except that when repeating a buffer with a BDD, you consider how long the grains will stay in the buffer (then it's called delay time), while when interpolating, you only need to know for how long to wait until the next grain (then it's delay length).
-
- Posts: 57
- Joined: 08 Jul 2016
Excellent explanation, thank you very much!
I got it for its spatial imaging but I'm really enjoying its character as a simple delay.
I got it for its spatial imaging but I'm really enjoying its character as a simple delay.
- manisnotabird
- Posts: 475
- Joined: 20 Feb 2015
- Location: Austin, TX
From the Steerpike manual:WongoTheSane wrote: I think I roughly understand the difference between IDL and BDD, if I'm wrong someone will correct me. This isn't meant to be a technical explanation, just an ELI5. The difference is only audible when modulating the delay, i.e. speeding it up or slowing it down, as compared to the original signal.
The easiest way to think about it, I think, is that BBD is emulating analog hardware (chorus/flange/ensemble/vibrato pedals or rackmount units for Chenille, delay pedals or rack mount units for Steerpike/Titus) while IDL is straightforward digital delay (chorus/flange/ensemble/vibrato effects are all based on very short delay times).Use this button to switch between BBD mode and IDL (Interpolated Delay Line) mode. IDL is the typical software digital delay.
With IDL mode you will avoid aliasing entirely (see Clock, below). More usefully it will allow you to have longer feedbacks,
even infinite feedbacks, without the sound degradation that would occur when using BBD mode, or with tape delays, even
with THD at minimum. As with Bypass/On/Off Switch Off, switching BBD mode will also instantly clear the delay line of all
active channels.
With this being said, how should I best take advantage of the BBD in these devices? Should I be automating the Clock or the Steer knob, or the BBD Stages?manisnotabird wrote:From the Steerpike manual:WongoTheSane wrote: I think I roughly understand the difference between IDL and BDD, if I'm wrong someone will correct me. This isn't meant to be a technical explanation, just an ELI5. The difference is only audible when modulating the delay, i.e. speeding it up or slowing it down, as compared to the original signal.The easiest way to think about it, I think, is that BBD is emulating analog hardware (chorus/flange/ensemble/vibrato pedals or rackmount units for Chenille, delay pedals or rack mount units for Steerpike/Titus) while IDL is straightforward digital delay (chorus/flange/ensemble/vibrato effects are all based on very short delay times).Use this button to switch between BBD mode and IDL (Interpolated Delay Line) mode. IDL is the typical software digital delay.
With IDL mode you will avoid aliasing entirely (see Clock, below). More usefully it will allow you to have longer feedbacks,
even infinite feedbacks, without the sound degradation that would occur when using BBD mode, or with tape delays, even
with THD at minimum. As with Bypass/On/Off Switch Off, switching BBD mode will also instantly clear the delay line of all
active channels.
-
- Information
-
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 103 guests