Page 1 of 2
Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by highmarcs
I'm getting ready to mix a project and would like to try doing it in Reason. However, I've always been stopped by the fact that Reason makes crossfading between two clips ridiculously hard with all kinds of steps.
Can someone tell me if they fixed this problem in Reason 10?
Can you just select a bunch of clips and hit "crossfade" in Reasson 10, like you can do in well... every other DAW?
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by Loque
highmarcs wrote: ↑23 Nov 2018
I'm getting ready to mix a project and would like to try doing it in Reason. However, I've always been stopped by the fact that Reason makes crossfading between two clips ridiculously hard with all kinds of steps.
Can someone tell me if they fixed this problem in Reason 10?
Can you just select a bunch of clips and hit "crossfade" in Reasson 10, like you can do in well... every other DAW?
Maybe you should use a different DAW if that supports the features you are lookig for.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by esselfortium
Comp edit is probably the most straightforward way of doing this in Reason. Join the audio clips into one (ctrl-J) and enter comp edit mode, then you can add crossfades wherever you want.
Loque wrote: ↑23 Nov 2018
highmarcs wrote: ↑23 Nov 2018
I'm getting ready to mix a project and would like to try doing it in Reason. However, I've always been stopped by the fact that Reason makes crossfading between two clips ridiculously hard with all kinds of steps.
Can someone tell me if they fixed this problem in Reason 10?
Can you just select a bunch of clips and hit "crossfade" in Reasson 10, like you can do in well... every other DAW?
Maybe you should use a different DAW if that supports the features you are lookig for.
Yikes.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by highmarcs
Well, I've owned Reason for years, but I kind of shelved it mostly because it's missing some basic features. I enjoy creating in Reason, but I've always had to do final mixing in Cubase or Studio One.
All I wanted to know was if they had fixed the convoluted crossfade protocol in Reason 10. That's all.
From your snarky response, I suppose the answer is no.
Back on the shelf it goes.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by Loque
highmarcs wrote: ↑23 Nov 2018
Well, I've owned Reason for years, but I kind of shelved it mostly because it's missing some basic features. I enjoy creating in Reason, but I've always had to do final mixing in Cubase or Studio One.
All I wanted to know was if they had fixed the convoluted crossfade protocol in Reason 10. That's all.
From your snarky response, I suppose the answer is no.
Back on the shelf it goes.
WTF is a convoluted crossfade protocoll?
Its just fade one track out the other in. Job done. Sometimes i just cant get the questions ppl ask here, especially with that troll tone.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by VariableX
is there not a black friday free plugin that cross fades two audio sources?
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 23 Nov 2018
by O1B
Read what you write. You're the one with the Troll Tone.
Dish it, but can't take it! The Usual Suspects...
To the OP, if you have Pongasoft A/B Switch, it should work swimmingly.
... it's just a lil convoluted.
Free:
https://shop.propellerheads.com/rack-ex ... cv-switch/
Loque wrote: ↑23 Nov 2018
Its just fade one track out the other in. Job done. Sometimes i just cant get the questions ppl ask here, especially with that troll tone.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Ahornberg
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by madmacman
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well, that's quick and easy!
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Skimrok
I can see why some like crossfader slider especially from a DJ background can relate to this method easy rather then drawing lines and curves in edit mode
On another note it would be cool if there was templates for automations so you could try different layout versions by a click of button for speed and various ideas you wouldn’t come up with yourself
just a thought while looking at this thread if It’s never been done in the past?
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by esselfortium
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
This is pretty close to how it works in comp edit mode. I often forget that it
exists, but when I do use it for crossfades it couldn't be much simpler.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Ahornberg
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
In Reaper, Live, Bitwig and most other DAWs crossfade is quick an easy.
The easiest way I know in Reason is this:
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by madmacman
@esselfortium / ahornberg: Yes, that's the best option for Reason.
Maybe the evaluation of convenience should be based on the question if crossfading is part of editing or arranging audio clips?
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by selig
esselfortium wrote:madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
This is pretty close to how it works in comp edit mode. I often forget that it
exists, but when I do use it for crossfades it couldn't be much simpler.
Well, except you have to join clips first, then you use your clip boundaries plus you can’t crossfade more than one track at a time and don’t have any crossfade options.
In Pro Tools, for comparison, you can crossfade every clip in the song with two commands: command-A, command-F and every clip is cross faded. I would suggest that is much simpler than in Reason.
Single crossfade are also simpler because you can specify by selecting an area and command F - which means crossfade can be asymmetrical or start/end on the clip boundary (which I use most of the time) again without loosing the clip boundaries.
Also there are crossfade options to choose from, and IIRC Reason has oddly shaped crossfades that can do strange things on longer crossfades.
I’ve always thought it was an odd extra step to have to enter a special mode just to crossfade a track...
Sent from some crappy device using Tapatalk
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by esselfortium
selig wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
esselfortium wrote:
This is pretty close to how it works in comp edit mode. I often forget that it exists, but when I do use it for crossfades it couldn't be much simpler.
Well, except you have to join clips first, then you use your clip boundaries plus you can’t crossfade more than one track at a time and don’t have any crossfade options.
In Pro Tools, for comparison, you can crossfade every clip in the song with two commands: command-A, command-F and every clip is cross faded. I would suggest that is much simpler than in Reason.
Single crossfade are also simpler because you can specify by selecting an area and command F - which means crossfade can be asymmetrical or start/end on the clip boundary (which I use most of the time) again without loosing the clip boundaries.
Also there are crossfade options to choose from, and IIRC Reason has oddly shaped crossfades that can do strange things on longer crossfades.
I’ve always thought it was an odd extra step to have to enter a special mode just to crossfade a track...
Sent from some crappy device using Tapatalk
That's valid, yeah! Not wanting to suggest there's no room for other more general-purpose methods of doing this, just making sure that the existing one isn't being overlooked.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Yonatan
Comp edit mode is handy only when it comes to what it is made for, chosing the best takes from recording a couple of versions of a guitar, bass, vocal part. But it was added back in "Record". I so much struggle in the sequencer when having many lanes of audio, like editing audio for radio or video. A good crossfade should be implemented in the main sequencer, not only in comp mode.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Ahornberg
Personally, I've never used crossfade in any of my tracks.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by Jolla
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
Sony vegas had this ability
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 24 Nov 2018
by raveled
Sorry for bringing up this Instagram-post again (I’ve already done it in a couple of threads before), but it hints that Propellerhead is working on cross fades (and have been for a while now, considering the post is getting old):
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by Eski
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by O1B
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by scratchnsnifff
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
Couldn’t you just place the clips next to each other and use the fade out and fade in dots on the audio clips?
And if you want better cross fading just move a clip in one of the tracks so it overlaps according to the time in which it’s played. Then adjust the fade amounts accordingly?
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by aeox
scratchnsnifff wrote: ↑26 Nov 2018
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
Couldn’t you just place the clips next to each other and use the fade out and fade in dots on the audio clips?
And if you want better cross fading just move a clip in one of the tracks so it overlaps according to the time in which it’s played. Then adjust the fade amounts accordingly?
This is exactly what I do.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by madmacman
scratchnsnifff wrote: ↑26 Nov 2018
madmacman wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
All suggestions seem to be tedious workarounds.
I can't remember *which* one, but I once had a DAW where I got instant (and visual) crossfades while dragging audio clips over each other in the same row. Well,
that's quick and easy!
Couldn’t you just place the clips next to each other and use the fade out and fade in dots on the audio clips?
And if you want better cross fading just move a clip in one of the tracks so it overlaps according to the time in which it’s played. Then adjust the fade amounts accordingly?
Sure, there are many ways to get a more or less working option for crossfades. But this solution takes some steps:
1. nude audio clip
2. check crossfade
3. adjust fades accordingly
4. repeat
It's not that it is impossible, but sometimes I'm getting desperate on how basic Reason's tools are in some ways. Especially for sophisticated audio editing (way beyond simple comping, or adjusting vocals) it is simply not the right tool, I have to realize. Maybe I should spend some money on a wave editor.
Re: Crossfading Audio In Reason?
Posted: 26 Nov 2018
by ejanuska
raveled wrote: ↑24 Nov 2018
Sorry for bringing up this Instagram-post again (I’ve already done it in a couple of threads before), but it hints that Propellerhead is working on cross fades (and have been for a while now, considering the post is getting old):
It looks like they are working on the sequencer. Notice there are only two clips and one track.
The guy is pointing and saying "Uhhh I think the user should click here and the browser should open in a folder other than the last opened folder."
The other guy is saying "Should we get another hot dog or go back to work? Ha ha ha! Two more dogs!!!"