david1806 wrote: ↑05 Apr 2020
All very interesting and very valid points - thanks!
The things you mention in your last paragraph joey I agree with, but I think I said before, that kind of thing isn't really what I mean, because as you say, they do take skill.
I guess the best thing, as suggested, is to give you some examples.....I can't think of any off the top of my head, as I don't use them, just seen the demos. When my FB advert is a piece of music software, it is quite often the sort of thing I am waffling on about.
I'll take a look........
If stuff like this is currently bothering you in any way, be prepared to have your head exploded in a few years…
It won't be long before AI "composers" create entire songs with the user specifying only things like composer style/emotion, genre/composer, tempo, key, length etc. But at that point you wouldn't even necessarily
need to specify anything at all, just roll the dice and a song will come out. It will be more like a current song library search engine, where you specify your desired mood and are directed to the songs that fit those "tags".
I see film directors using this type of technology initially, to get instant scores that fit the length, emotion, and chosen style of the film. For example, let's say you need a 30 second hero's theme in the style of John Williams - bam, you got it. Don't like something about it? Change a few settings and try again.
Sure, it will sound clunky and contrived at first, sort of like a "first year" film composer (!). But assuming humans are still around in 50-100 years, it will eventually get refined and improved. Just like when DJs came on the scene and live bands were hired less (or when cars replaced horses), you'll have to adapt. Or choose a different career - or be a hold out because eventually "real" composer WILL come back in fashion.
Just like gas, and then electric lighting replaces candles and lanterns, which then became "passé" - but then came back as "fancy/designer" items after a time, live musicians can survive the DJs, tape playback, samplers, arpeggiators, note generators, and even AI. Some folks will always prefer riding horses, candlelight dinners, and some will always prefer live music/musicians. Change is inevitable, at least in this universe…