Thats all fine and dandy. It would be stupid to buy a macbook if you simply want to buy horsepower and its great that with Windows and Linux (actually Windows less so lately) theres flexible, open systems where the user can combine and configure hard- and software as he likes, choosing prices, performance, configuration etc.sublunar wrote:Still, I'm confident that with minimal effort on ebay used PC's are still cheaper than their Apple equivalents. I'm comparing my Dell e6520 (2.9GHZ i7 which runs Reason 8 and Arturia and inside of which I have two SSDs) to a similar Macbook pro A1425 which is going for $419 on up (way up). The e6520 starts at $159 with free shipping. I don't have all day to compare, but I'm not surprised by my initial findings.
However theres another way to look at it and thats "I want the services these devices can provide". Like with a smartphone or a gaming console. For both you can go and build them yourself as well. You can buy a GPU and storage and display for a phone as well - you can also build your own gaming console. But nobody does that because paying the price for the existing services (Galaxy Phone, iPhone, XBox, Playstation) are fine and you get the working service. But these are restricted so they can work fine. Theres only specific hardware which makes supporting it in the software easier and more bug free etc.
The Mac is somewhere in between consoles and PCs in that regard, a lot is not configurable, theres only several hardware configurations. But with that you get relatively hassle-free software and - heres the main thing about price - very inexpensive professional software directly from the hardware manufacturer! Look at the price of Final Cut Pro or Logic and compare it to the available software for PC like Cubase or Premiere, then look again what you have to pay for the additional software that comes with it (i.e. Motion, Logics instruments, effects and sound banks!).
So you say you'd be stupid to buy a CPU and a hard disk from Apple but I say you'd be stupid to buy your first music making computer from any other company - you will definitely pay more if you buy a PC (and don't crack software-aherm)
What I like in my professional work is that I get the Mac, I unpack it, I install the software, connect the interface and go. With a PC I spend at least one day to configure it properly, I guess thats what Selig also alluded to. But thats personal experience, I am sure with the right PC supplier and time spent beforehand investigating the options and preparing the installation that could be cut as well.