Chizmata wrote:
i can agree so much on many of that. fact is, we dont know how far a different approach would have taken props. maybe every pure electronic musician would have reason at home as his standard tool now, while recording guys still never heard of it. the risk when you widen your approach is to lose the core and not really attract the rest too much - and also lose quality in what initially made you big, while youre always behind trying to adapt to other DAWS strenghths.
quoting myself on the analogue thing:
i would have wished for something more dedicated than nektar panorama. lets say something that has enough, faders, knobs and buttons to theoretically completely control any existing reason device without switching modes or layouts. on top there could be a digital display naming each knobs and faders function depending to which device you switch.
Just out of interest have you tried RsTouch? This is really the closest you're gonna get to what you want. There's really no way that one physical device could ever accommodate every possible Reason device, stock or otherwise. How would a single page controller for Thor work? And how would it adapt to ReDrum, or Parsec, or NN-XT? RsTouch is a great solution to this IMO. Any controller that came even close to this would probably cost at leas as much as an iPad Air 2 or Pro + a compact audio/MIDI interface, so might as well just get one of those and then you can have a more tactile interface. Plus a sweet tablet haha. You can even sequence ReDrum with it! Which is pretty damn cool. Just an idea. I know it's not quite knobs and faders but it's the closest you'll get for now
Losing the core user has always been a risk - I felt they came close to doing that for a while, back when Reason wasn't even prominent on the website and everything was about singer-songwriters with an acoustic guitar and a macbook, making music on Figure and Take. That was a dark time
I think now the focus is squarely back on Reason, and once people cross over and start dipping their toes into the modular world their minds will be blown. Maybe once a few videos surface of what's possible with 9.5 you might feel differently. Never say never!